+- Comfort Automation/ Security System Forums (https://www.comfortforums.com)
+-- Forum: Third Party (interfacing to Comfort) (https://www.comfortforums.com/forum-5.html)
+--- Forum: X10 (https://www.comfortforums.com/forum-33.html)
+--- Thread: What to use to replace X10 (/thread-3626.html)
- mccltd - 11-27-2013
I\'m upgrading my comfort 1 to a 2 shortly and at the same time think it maybe time to replace my 10 year old X10 modules.
I currently use soft touch X10 light switches and appliance modules around the house.
What is now the most cost effective route to go that the comfort ii will control please?
regards
Dave.
- mikegriff - 11-27-2013
As dimming is a problem now with LED.
I would suggest relays with Comfort
plus contactors where heavy current is needed.
Mike
- ident - 11-28-2013
The closest replacement for X10 may be Zwave but more complicated to setup and may have problems with certain manufacturers, see the Zwave forum
Other alternatives are Velbus, Cbus, KNX
- juwi_uk - 11-28-2013
Quote:As dimming is a problem now with LED
Please expand as im using dimmable LED with zwave.
juwi
- mccltd - 11-28-2013
Thanks for the advise. Looks like i will give zwave a go.
Can I use this on my comfort 1 till I install my upgrade?
Is there a simple guide to programming Zwave that you can recommend?
Also Juwi_uk what wave device do you use with Led as I have quite a few LED Gu10\'s in my house that I can\'t currently control with an X10 light switch.
Many thanks
Dave
- juwi_uk - 11-28-2013
I am using Fibraro dimmers with bypass module (needed for LEDs if load <25w) fitted. My LEDs are various, some dim some dont. My dimming ones are Philips LedSpot mv gu10 in a couple of variations; some ie kitchen are recessed and others retrofit to existing ceiling fittings.
Julian
- wexfordman - 11-28-2013
Hi Mcc,
I did same recently (about two years ago) and I went the velbus route and haven\'t regretted it.
Did an overview on it which you can find here if you are interested https://docs.google.com/a/glenegare.com/file/d/0B1zlDoqP2HdxNWd0LXdhWGRIVW8/edit?usp=docslist_api
- ident - 11-28-2013
Yes, velbus is an excellent solution if you dont need wireless, very stable and easy to configure