+- Comfort Automation/ Security System Forums (https://www.comfortforums.com)
+-- Forum: Third Party (interfacing to Comfort) (https://www.comfortforums.com/forum-5.html)
+--- Forum: Zwave (https://www.comfortforums.com/forum-62.html)
+--- Thread: Zwave and Cbus/other Lighting Platforms (/thread-3916.html)
- juwi_uk - 08-10-2014
The Object Matrix in my latest ComfortClient version may be of help here as you can monitor the situation over a period and then just output the history for the selected counters.
I have noticed a similar \"counter flicker\" with one of my ZWave responses when testing the Object Matrix. I have a door sensor and PIR that, at night, the light is meant to turn on when somebody enters from outside. The response works fine but I think it creates a lot of counter updates for some reason which I\'ve yet to debug myself.
Anyway just a thought.
Julian
- Howser - 08-11-2014
There are no responses or any other references to this counter except Zwave.
- ident - 08-27-2014
Hi Howser
Is this issue resolved? Does it happen again?
- Howser - 08-29-2014
I have been logging activity on Zwave side (with NO CBUS mapping) and I could not reproduce the issue.
I will re-map CBUS and see if that makes any difference.
- Howser - 09-05-2014
It is still occurring. When it does, the GA is turned ON and then OFF a couple of times (from CBUS it looks like Comfort is doing it). Most of the time, ON is immediately followed by OFF.
Code:
2014/09/05 03:16:07 AM Lighting Group= 100 Unit= 127 Event= Group on
2014/09/05 03:16:07 AM Lighting Group= 100 Unit= 127 Event= Group off
2014/09/05 03:16:22 AM Lighting Group= 100 Unit= 127 Event= Group on
2014/09/05 03:16:23 AM Lighting Group= 100 Unit= 127 Event= Group off- ident - 09-06-2014
To determine the cause of this, we need the Bus Monitor
This will show what causes the counters (or flags ) to switch on or off
- Howser - 09-10-2014
I have emailed the logs to support.
- ident - 09-13-2014
The Bus monitor log shows the the UCM/Zwave (UCM ID 4) is triggering the Counters 100 and 253 from a multichannel device. The counters 100 is mapped to your cbus Family Room side lamp, while 253 is not mapped to any Cbus group
You wil have to investigate why the zwave channels are triggered from the Zwave device
- Howser - 09-17-2014
I will investigate Zwave side.
- Howser - 10-01-2014
I investigated the Zwave side and looking at the logs (attached), I can see the node being polled, but nothing purely switching the node ON and OFF.
08 09/30/14 22:47:41.504 JobHandler_LuaUPnP::HandleActionRequest argument serviceId=urn:micasaverde-com
erviceId:HomeAutomationGateway1 <0x2d9db680>08 09/30/14 22:47:41.504 JobHandler_LuaUPnP::HandleActionRequest argument action=LogIpRequest <0x2d9db680>
08 09/30/14 22:47:41.504 JobHandler_LuaUPnP::HandleActionRequest argument IpAddress=192.168.2.232 <0x2d9db680>
08 09/30/14 22:47:41.505 JobHandler_LuaUPnP::HandleActionRequest argument MacAddress=34:e2:fd:1e:1e:da <0x2d9db680>
02 09/30/14 22:47:45.103 [33;1mZW_Send_Data node 19 NO ROUTE (nil)[0m <0x2b7db680>
02 09/30/14 22:47:47.233 [33;1mZW_Send_Data node 19 NO ROUTE (nil)[0m <0x2b7db680>
02 09/30/14 22:48:09.372 [33;1mZWaveSerial::GetFrame 0x2b7daef0 timed out now 0 m_listGetFramePending 0[0m <0x2b7db680>
02 09/30/14 22:48:09.372 [33;1mZWaveJobHandler::SendDataAbort got m_iFrameID 0[0m <0x2b7db680>
02 09/30/14 22:48:09.373 [33;1mZWJob_PollNode::ReturnMessageNotReceived -end- job job#865 :pollnode #19 dev:44 (0xb1ed80) N:19 P:100 S:5 node 19 didn\'t reply iOK 25 iBadTx 0 iNoReply 25 Abort returned m_iFrameID 0[0m <0x2b7db680>
02 09/30/14 22:48:09.373 [33;1mZWJob_PollNode:
ollFailed job job#865 :pollnode #19 dev:44 (0xb1ed80) N:19 P:100 S:5 node 19 battery 0[0m <0x2b7db680>06 09/30/14 22:48:09.373 Device_Variable::m_szValue_set device: 1 service: urn:micasaverde-com
erviceId:ZWaveNetwork1 variable: [35;1mLastError[0m was: Poll failed now: Poll failed #hooks: 0 upnp: 0 v:0xa147a8/NONE duplicate:1 <0x2b7db680>04 09/30/14 22:48:09.374 <Job ID=\"865\" Name=\"pollnode #19 3 cmds\" Device=\"44\" Created=\"2014-09-30 22:47:45\" Started=\"2014-09-30 22:47:45\" Completed=\"2014-09-30 22:48:09\" Duration=\"24.273150000\" Runtime=\"24.272377000\" Status=\"Failed\" LastNote=\"\" Node=\"19\" NodeType=\"ZWaveMultiEmbedded\" NodeDescription=\"Family Room Side Lamp\"/> <0x2b7db680>
02 09/30/14 22:48:09.375 [33;1mJobHandler:
urgeCompletedJobs purge job#865 :pollnode #19 dev:44 (0xb1ed80) N:19 P:100 S:2 pollnode #19 3 cmds status 2[0m <0x2b7db680>50 09/30/14 22:48:20.110 luup_log:17: Received: unknowncommand 14 <0x2d5db680>
02 09/30/14 22:48:55.104 [33;1mZW_Send_Data node 19 NO ROUTE (nil)[0m <0x2b7db680>
02 09/30/14 22:48:57.243 [33;1mZW_Send_Data node 19 NO ROUTE (nil)[0m <0x2b7db680>
02 09/30/14 22:48:59.402 [33;1mZW_Send_Data node 19 NO ROUTE (nil)[0m <0x2b7db680>
04 09/30/14 22:48:59.552 <Job ID=\"866\" Name=\"pollnode #19 3 cmds\" Device=\"44\" Created=\"2014-09-30 22:48:55\" Started=\"2014-09-30 22:48:55\" Completed=\"2014-09-30 22:48:59\" Duration=\"4.451047000\" Runtime=\"4.449414000\" Status=\"Successful\" LastNote=\"\" Node=\"19\" NodeType=\"ZWaveMultiEmbedded\" NodeDescription=\"Family Room Side Lamp\"/> <0x2b3db680>
50 09/30/14 22:49:20.110 luup_log:17: Received: unknowncommand 14 <0x2d5db680>
08 09/30/14 22:49:50.112 JobHandler_LuaUPnP::HandleActionRequest device: 0 service: urn:micasaverde-com
erviceId:HomeAutomationGateway1 action: [36;1mLogIpRequest[0m <0x2d9db680>08 09/30/14 22:49:50.112 JobHandler_LuaUPnP::HandleActionRequest argument serviceId=urn:micasaverde-com
erviceId:HomeAutomationGateway1 <0x2d9db680>08 09/30/14 22:49:50.112 JobHandler_LuaUPnP::HandleActionRequest argument action=LogIpRequest <0x2d9db680>
08 09/30/14 22:49:50.113 JobHandler_LuaUPnP::HandleActionRequest argument IpAddress=192.168.2.225 <0x2d9db680>
08 09/30/14 22:49:50.113 JobHandler_LuaUPnP::HandleActionRequest argument MacAddress=38:0f:4a:9a:bd:57 <0x2d9db680>
50 09/30/14 22:50:20.110 luup_log:17: Received: unknowncommand 14 <0x2d5db680>
02 09/30/14 22:50:25.103 [33;1mZW_Send_Data node 19 NO ROUTE (nil)[0m <0x2b7db680>
02 09/30/14 22:50:27.232 [33;1mZW_Send_Data node 19 NO ROUTE (nil)[0m <0x2b7db680>
02 09/30/14 22:50:29.373 [33;1mZW_Send_Data node 19 NO ROUTE (nil)[0m <0x2b7db680>
04 09/30/14 22:50:29.502 <Job ID=\"867\" Name=\"pollnode #19 3 cmds\" Device=\"44\" Created=\"2014-09-30 22:50:25\" Started=\"2014-09-30 22:50:25\" Completed=\"2014-09-30 22:50:29\" Duration=\"4.401062000\" Runtime=\"4.399755000\" Status=\"Successful\" LastNote=\"\" Node=\"19\" NodeType=\"ZWaveMultiEmbedded\" NodeDescription=\"Family Room Side Lamp\"/>